A spacious green backyard with a mature live oak and a small terrace beside a pale stucco home in south Lakeland.

Where the Money Goes in a Highlands Grove South Home and a Touchstone New Build

In Highland Homes' Touchstone community, off Crews Lake Drive in Lakeland, a move-in-ready four-bedroom Parker plan with 1,715 square feet is listed at $359,900. It was $369,915 before the builder marked it down. A short drive away in the Highlands area, Highlands Grove South has single-story homes from the late 1970s and 1980s on lots of about a third of an acre. The two are on most south Lakeland shortlists this season, and the list price is the least useful way to compare them.

The builder's money this holiday season goes mostly toward your monthly payment. A Highlands Grove South home's price is carried in large part by its land, and in October 2026 a vacant lot on Strickland Avenue sold for a figure that tells you what that land is worth.

What Highlands Grove South Is

The Polk County Property Appraiser records the neighborhood as two plats: Highlands Grove South, recorded in Plat Book 66, Page 23, and Highlands Grove South Phase Two, in Plat Book 78. The parcels sit in unincorporated Polk County and have Lakeland 33812 mailing addresses. Most of the homes front Strickland Avenue, and Waterman Lane is part of it too.

The Property Appraiser's parcel records describe a consistent street. In ten developed parcels across both phases, the homes were built between 1978 and 1992, have between 1,433 and 1,857 square feet of living area, and sit on lots of 0.33 to 0.36 acre. One Phase Two lot is 0.73 acre and carries a screened pool added in 2017 and a steel-frame outbuilding from 2010. Most of the houses are wood frame with wood, vinyl or aluminum siding. A few are block with stucco, and one Phase Two home has a metal roof.

Owners have built onto these lots over the decades. The parcel records show pools added in 1984, 2001, 2017 and 2022, along with screen rooms and detached garages from the 1980s. A third of an acre leaves room for that kind of addition, and buyers here are paying for that room.

The October Lot Sale That Priced the Land

In October 2026, Lot 19 in the original Highlands Grove South plat changed hands for $59,000 on a warranty deed. It's a vacant 0.33-acre residential parcel on Strickland Avenue. It's the same size as nearly every developed lot around it, so it's the clearest current price for the land under any home on the street.

Hold that figure against the neighborhood's most recent home sales on record. In January 2023, a 1980 block-and-stucco home on Lot 21 with 1,433 square feet sold for $290,000. In March 2023, the 1982 wood-frame home next door on Lot 18, with 1,546 square feet, sold for $280,000. Those 2023 prices come to roughly $181 to $202 per square foot of living area. Today's two marked-down Touchstone move-ins come to roughly $189 to $210 per square foot.

The per-foot figures land close together, and the land is what makes them different purchases. If a third of an acre on Strickland Avenue is worth about $59,000 as of October 2026, then about a fifth of a $290,000 price is land. The house itself is the smaller share of what a buyer is paying for. A 40-year-old house wears out, and the land under it holds its value or gains.

Older sales show the same pattern. The 1978 block home on Waterman Lane sold for $249,900 in August 2021 and had a pool added in 2022. The 0.73-acre Phase Two lot with its outbuilding sold for $330,000 in October 2021. The largest lot in the sample brought the highest price, and the house on it, built in 1986, is no bigger than its neighbors.

What the Builder's Holiday Money Pays For

Highland Homes' "Home for the Holidays" promotion runs for contracts signed from November 1 through December 31, 2026. It advertises up to $41,000 off select quick move-in homes and closing costs paid, including mortgage prepaids, worth up to $22,000. It also includes a builder-paid buydown of the interest rate. Together the builder puts the savings at "up to $63,000." The terms require financing through a Highland Homes lender partner, and the price cuts apply only to select homes. The full $63,000 is the most a buyer can get, and most buyers will get less.

Look at where the money goes. The closing-cost credit and the rate buydown lower the cash you need at the closing table and the monthly payment after it. The price reductions on the two Touchstone move-ins listed above come to roughly $10,000 each. The larger share of the advertised value goes to closing costs and the rate, so a buyer comparing Touchstone with a resale home is comparing a payment-focused incentive with a land-heavy price.

Touchstone has its own recurring costs. Highland Homes lists the community with a CDD and HOA dues of $150 a year. It describes the pool, clubhouse and playground as under development. Those charges belong in the same column as the incentives when you line the two homes up, and our earlier post on two Polk County homes with the same price tag looks at that side-by-side. This is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm your own numbers with the right professional.

What the Wider Lakeland Market Says About Negotiating

Resale sellers have room to deal this season too. In September 2026, Lakeland REALTORS counted 325 sales in its Lakeland report, an average sale price of $371,232 against an average list price of $379,605, and a 98% list-to-sale ratio. It also counted 1,465 active listings, or 4.51 months of inventory. Florida Realtors put the Lakeland–Winter Haven single-family median at $325,000 for September 2026, down 1.5% from a year earlier, on 905 closed sales, down 8.8%.

That means a market with four and a half months of supply where buyers close, on average, about 2% under list. A Highlands Grove South seller can't match a builder's lender program. A resale seller can still agree to a lower price, contribute toward closing costs, or credit a buyer for a roof or air conditioning system that's near the end of its life. When you compare the two homes, put the builder's concessions next to what a resale seller in this market is likely to negotiate, not next to the resale list price.

Weighing the Two With a Builder's Eye

With his builder-family background, Brian prices older homes on condition first and age second. On Strickland Avenue the questions are specific. Wood and vinyl siding on a 1980s frame house needs a different maintenance schedule than block and stucco, and both types sit side by side on this street. A pool added in 2022 is a different purchase from one built with the house in 1984. A detached garage or steel outbuilding on a larger lot can be worth real money to a buyer with a boat, a trailer or a workshop. A new home at Touchstone comes with new systems, open-concept layouts, and granite or quartz counters, according to the builder. You'll pay for those features in the price and in the community's recurring charges.

Vacant third-acre parcels in an established subdivision don't come up often. When one sells, a new house is likely to follow, and new houses on these streets tend to raise what buyers expect for the street. If you want a new build, a lot in Highlands Grove South is also an option, and October's $59,000 sale gives you a starting point for the land cost.

If you're new to this part of town, our guide to the scrub trail and the Lakeland Highlands Road corridor covers what's near Highlands Grove South day to day.

A Few Quick Answers

Is Highlands Grove South inside Lakeland city limits? The Property Appraiser lists its parcels as unincorporated Polk County with Lakeland 33812 mailing addresses.

When does the Highland Homes holiday offer end? It covers contracts signed from November 1 through December 31, 2026, financed through a Highland Homes lender partner.

Are there larger lots in the neighborhood? Most lots are about a third of an acre. At least one Phase Two parcel is 0.73 acre.

If you're deciding between a builder's year-end deal and a home on a third of an acre in Highlands Grove South, Brian Stephens can line up both on what you'd actually pay, including the land, the concessions and the recurring costs. If you already own on Strickland Avenue and want to know what October's lot sale means for your house, start with your instant home valuation and then give us a call.

Let’s Make Your Next Move

Moving doesn't have to be stressful. With the right guidance, it can be smooth, strategic, and successful. Reach out to Brian and let's make your next move the right one.

Follow Me on Instagram